Page 1 of 1

FA cup 2005 and penalties

Posted: Sun May 22, 2005 10:21 pm
by vector
Well I thought it was a good match, my dad was an avid utd supporter and I think would have been proud if he were still around to watch.It contained some great football mainly by the young lads running Utd's wings. Once again maybe the better side on the day didnt take home the spoils but how true is this of life. Is it wrong for a side who know they are "out gunned" to sit back and play spider tactics. Sometimes relying on luck is a good strategy.
Once again the debate rages over penalty solutions to drawn matches.
ohh dear. Lets see, if Arsenal had been given a penalty during the match and it turned out to be the only goal would we still cry over spilt milk.
The bottom line is this we need an end result.
the fans have to leave at a certain time to maintain logistics, like train and bus times etc. You cant have super athletes playing until they drop. Its not healthy. You cant keep extending the time or workign on golden goals silly ness. If no one could score in 90 odd minutes and then the "this is your last chance" extra time wasn't enough to stir up something magical then I guess the other team deserves it. Weather they look the better team or not is irrelevant, the rule is: who scores the most in the allotted time wins.
Athleticism, skill and tactics were unable to secure a result. The fact that it then falls to some luck, nerves, instinct and deep down raw inner strength I believe is as fair an indicator as anything else.

Or maybe we should all sit in our comfy armchairs and push vote buttons to determine "who should be voted out" like some reality TV show.

Arsenal. you were lucky.
Utd you played the better game and the world saw and knows it. Your fans should be proud.
I thank you both for a good evenings viewing.
and like the good loyal dog that I am .. Ill stick to Spurs ;)

Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 4:38 pm
by mom2pp
but think about it:
if spurs were in the cup final and had been out played by, arsenal say, for the whole game and it was 0-0 after extra time would you like it if you didnt get a fair chance to win the game on penalties?
if it was liverpool i would certainly want the game to go onto penalties.
i wasnt sure from your post whether you liked penalty shoot outs or not but i certainly think they are a good fair way to decide a drawn game.
oh well i hope liverpool win the champions league without the need for penalties because that would be just to tense for me :wink:
will you be watching the game on wednesday?

Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 4:51 pm
by atd
I'll listen to the match wednesday (We have no tv, we'll listen to the radio).
We both prefer another team:
Arne Deprez wrote:Go AC Milan,
atd
Tobe Deprez wrote:Go Liverpool,
atd

Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 4:59 pm
by mom2pp
im glad at least one of you will be supporting liverpool :wink:

Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 5:22 pm
by gyboth
mom2pp wrote:will you be watching the game on wednesday?
i don't think i'll watch the whole match, i'm not a fan of either team. i rooted for bayern and a bit for barcelona, but now i'm that interested anymore ;-)

gyözö

Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 6:15 pm
by mom2pp
i don't think i'll watch the whole match, i'm not a fan of either team. i rooted for bayern and a bit for barcelona, but now i'm that interested anymore Wink
you should be cheering on liverpool because they knocked out chelsea who knocked out bayern and barcelona :wink:

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 6:06 am
by vector
yes I support penalties.
and yes all tho it hurts me to say

I will be supporting des liver birdies :P

I probably will watch it,, the euro matches are one of the few games we can see free to air...mind you it will be at 4am ish

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 6:34 am
by gyboth
mom2pp wrote:you should be cheering on liverpool because they knocked out chelsea who knocked out bayern and barcelona :wink:
sounds logical :lol: they have hamann, too, who's a cool bavarian chap.
on the other hand, shevchenko's a superb player, too :-)

gyözö

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:29 pm
by mom2pp
gyboth wrote: on the other hand, shevchenko's a superb player, too :-)
yes i think shevchenko is a really good player too

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:32 pm
by atd
Arne Deprez:

I hope he'll score some times!!

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:39 pm
by mom2pp
atd wrote:I hope he'll score some times!!
i hope you're wrong but i think that if anyone scores for milan it will be him

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 5:55 pm
by gyboth
atd wrote:(We have no tv, we'll listen to the radio)
you have no tv but (at least one) computer? what kind of household is that? :shock:

gyözö

Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 10:53 am
by atd
gyboth wrote:
atd wrote:(We have no tv, we'll listen to the radio)
you have no tv but (at least one) computer? what kind of household is that? :shock:
We have about 7 computers in use for 6 persons (1 server).

Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 11:35 am
by gyboth
atd wrote:We have about 7 computers in use for 6 persons (1 server).
let me guess.. every male has 2 computers and all the females together have one :lol:

gyözö

Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 12:34 pm
by atd
Only one female :lol: , a few years ago she used the computer we (me + tobe) didn't need anymore. :lol: